keskiviikko 20. lokakuuta 2010

Education and health

Women participating a self-esteem workshop in Huaycán, Peru.

Education is considered to be the most powerful tool in reducing poverty, gender inequality and unequal social structures in the world. Education empowers and offers people tools for a brighter future. Education gives hope and helps people to live in peace with each other. Education is especially considered to have a greater influence amongst women as educating a girl or a woman can mean educating the whole village, reducing illnesses, child mortality rates and increasing participation in the society. No one can deny the great influence that education has got in people’s health and quality of life. However, there is also a lot of discussion that education should be culture sensitive, that the same western models should not be directly adapted to other continents, and that education should not only mean literacy and numeracy, since it can be quite a limited perspective to education. I think that non-formal education is also something that should also be seriously considered in developing processes, given that for many people living in developing countries it might be more accessible than the formal education. Non-formal education is many times offered by non-profits and NGO’s and which include in their educational policies the real needs of the individuals, when the formal education is many times strictly tied with the national policies. Nevertheless, also the formal education has immense influence on the individuals and nations wellbeing, at least when it is accessible for everybody. The table that I am going to analyse is based on the formal education process; the primary/secondary school attendance and literacy rates. (UNICEF 2008a).


Women participating a self-esteem workshop in Huaycán, Peru.
I also choose to do my analyse by exploring the differences within countries of each continent, since I think that because of the local realities; because of the historical, social and cultural reasons it’s more meaningful to analyse the table between countries that share similar kind of reality than for instance an African country compared with a country from another continent. I will not be able to analyse all the countries, so I choose just few countries and write about them briefly. In order to make some limitations I will also leave out the so called "North" and consentrate more on the "Southern" countries. However, I do not deny that there would be many things to improve in Europe or in the USA.




Asia

Asia shares such disparities within the continent that it makes it quite difficult to understand the differences in the access of education. On the other hand the differences can also help in explaining the varieties; some of these varieties can be ethnical, cultural, religious or political ones. In the table the first country is Afghanistan which of course shows very large gender inequality. Only 51% of the boys are literate, but the number of girls is shockingly low: 18%. In the case of Afghanistan the Taleban regime oppresses women very strongly and the rates can be explained by that. On the other hand Bangladesh doesn’t show such inequality between the boys and girls, even if it considered being one of the poorest countries of the world. However, the rates in general are low. China is a country with a strong economy and military power, at the same time the freedom of speech is very limited. Independently of that, the literacy and schooling rates are very good and show very little difference between men and women. Surprising after the education rates the number of internet users is very low, even if it could be explained by the lack of freedom of speech which is controlled by the nation. Nepal has a large difference between the genders and women’s literacy rate in 20% lower then men’s. In the last years there has been, however, positive change in under-five mortality rates, infant mortality rates and in reproductive health as a result of education process. (Unicef, 2010.) India in general shows quite a good young male literacy rates, but also there girls have a lot less access to education. India has got the fastest growing population in the world, so educating girls would be extremely important for the future. However, it seems difficult (but not impossible) to brake the tradition of the importance of the male in the society.


Latin America

Latin America is known for male chauvinism, discrimination against the indigenous populations and for the very large gap between the rich and the poor. Despite of that, some of the countries share almost the same living standards as the countries of the “North” (Chile being one example of that). Guatemala and Bolivia are one of the poorest countries in Latin America, but still the literacy rates seem to be fairly high. Guatemala has the biggest gap between the male and female literacy rates and in all the lowest of Latin America. Surprisingly, the disparity between the girls and boys does not show in the overall rates of the continent. However, the internet user rates seem to be fairly low compared to the literacy rates that is because many people just not have a possibility to use it or does not know how to do it. Guatemala and Bolivia also have the highest indigenous populations among the Latin American countries and that causes difficulties in the schooling process. The indigenous languages are often not taken into consideration in the formal school system; the children need to study in their second language and that may also lead into loosing their traditional culture and being ashamed of their roots. There is also another thing to take into consideration; as I mentioned before we should not only watch the literacy rates and the statistics, but also the quality of the education. In many countries which have high rates, the quality is still lacking and the disparities between the social classes are large. In Peru, for example, the literacy rates are high for both genders, but according the Worldfund in year 2007 Peru’s educational system was ranked 133rd out of 134 countries. Peru also spends less than three percent of its GDP on education and many of the teachers are not qualified. (Wordfund, 2010.)


Africa

According to the table Africa is the continent that in overall has the lowest rates in literacy, schooling and internet and mobile phone usage. Nonetheless, the difference between the Northern Africa and Sub-Saharan Africa is very large. As we all know Sub-Saharan Africa is many times referred as the area which most needs action in fighting the poverty, hunger and inequality. Many African countries gained their independence much later than many of the other colonized nations and has the continent suffered decades of wars, political restlessness and exploitation as ex-colonies of European countries. Not to mention the challenge of fighting the present HIV/Aids epidemic. Among the Sub-Saharan Africa Zimbabwe and South-Africa seem to have the highest literacy rates and almost no difference between the men and the women; however, compared to many other countries the use of mobile phone seems to be much higher in South Africa. The literacy rates are very low in Mali, Niger, Sierra Leone and Ethiopia (etc.) and also the access to education between boys and girls is extremely high. In some countries as Ethiopia the reason not to go to school for many children can be the infrastructure or the income of the family: the schools can be very far away and parents need their children to work for the living. Nevertheless, the gender issue is to be taken seriously and cannot only be explained by cultural issues. Uganda is often mentioned as an example of developing their school system. In year 1996 the president decided to remove the primary school fees for up to four children of one family (amongst them two were aught be girls). This is how the key obstacle was removed and the families were sent an important message. Since then the primary school attendance has increased by 20%, even if the attendance of the girls is still 10% lower. However, at the same time the quality of the education has suffered. (The World Bank, 2002.)


Pictures by Chascona


Sources:


  • Worldfund 2010. URL: http://www.worldfund.org/Peru.html
  • The World Bank 2002. URL: http://siteresources.worldbank.org/EDUCATION/Resources/Education-Notes/EduNotesUganda.pdf
  • UNICEF 2010. URL: http://www.unicef.org/infobycountry/nepal_nepal_statistics.html
  • UNICEF 2008. URL: http://www.unicef.org/sowc08/docs/sowc08_table_5.pdf 
  • UNICEF 2008. Basic education and gender equality.
  • - Education for all
  • - The big picture
  • The World Bank 2008. Education and Development.
  • The World Bank 2008. Girls' education.

6 kommenttia:

  1. Hi chascona,
    I really liked your thorough analyze about education all over the world. As it can be seen in your text the education varies a lot and it is not always related to poverty eather.
    You write about the thing that western models shouldn't be adapted directly to developing countries. I couldn't agree more. Lots of the problems that has caused development aid ineffective is because of this kind of approaches earlier. This is also related to the second thing that you mentioned, the non-formal education. I too think that the education should improve the needed skills and people should also participate on planning the education. I realize that this is only possible to adult education and perhaps only in NGO related education, but nevertheless this is a really good way to help people to gain better income and reduce poverty.

    In analyzing different continents you have also mentioned the gender related problems. I agree with you that the womens education is crucial to improve society. But when I thought things further it came to my mind that in case of gender equality the boys education is just as important. With this I mean that both boys and girls should be taught to appreciate both genders and see them as equal. I know that this may sound very difficult task but maybe someday this could be possible.

    Your blog was interesting to read, thank you!

    VirveR

    VastaaPoista
  2. Thank you for your comment VirveR!

    I agree with you about the importance of educating boys, since educated men are aften also more equal in their relationships, more aware of the gender issues and more eager to educate their daughters as well. As you say: boys also need education to see women as equal to them. The change cannot happen only with the efforts of women, but it needs understandment from the both genders.

    I enjoyed reading your blog as well, you had many interesting examples and details:-)

    VastaaPoista
  3. Hi chascona,
    I liked your approach to the education subject - on the beginning of your blog you showed the point, the aim of education all over the world very clearly and transparently. You have also focused on non-formal education which you think should be seriously considered in developing processes - I totally agree with you. Unfortunately non-formal education is hard to measure because of lack of data and information gathered about it. It was very nice to read your blog also because of the fact that you had divided it in four parts - but for me the most interesting was the third part where you described Latin America and the case of Peru, which is placed almost on the end of the rank on the 133 position. It's unbelievable for me that the teachers can be not qualified.
    Regards
    Mikolaj

    VastaaPoista
  4. Hello Chascona,
    I agree with you that education is important for humans oneself. Really true, it is more than that is it only imprtant for live saving. But I think it is important for that, too. It is diffcult, because if the girl is needed at home on a field for example, so that the family have enough food, then I understand, why education is in that situation not so important. I think it is not possible in that countries to think at itself in respect to education, there is a community of people such as in a family and if they want to survive, they decide what is the best for the whole, and not, that education is an important value….. we can think that, but we have other possibilities and we are in oother situations. I think in that countries there are other values and not the value to get education to get a good outcome.
    Regards,
    Brinii

    VastaaPoista
  5. Thank you Mikolaj for your comment!
    What you say about non-formal education beeing difficult to measure is totally right. There is very few data about the educational projects offered by NGO´s or other kind of non-formal learning processes. Also within an education based NGO it´s also sometimes frustrating because the results of education show in a long life span and are not necessarely immediately so visible.

    VastaaPoista
  6. Hi Brinii!
    What you say about pover people not beeing able to consider education as an important value because of the daily struggle of surviving is complitely right. My point of educating girls just because they are as important as men comes more from the fact how we always justify women´s education by other reasons - that it´s beneficial for their children and the society around them. For example in Mexico they have had very good results by paying poor families for their children´s school attendance. This money often also goes for the mother, so that she gets more power and uses it on the children. Maybe this could be something to try in other continents as well, so that families could afford their children going to school instead of working for income of helping their families.

    VastaaPoista